There are
no cardinal rules in the bow technique
The bow technique has been carefully
studied over many centuries but there is no fixed rules.
Of course the basics in the use of the bow is universally
same but the high level of bow technique used by the
world class performers use a unique way of using the
bow that is extremely individual. This can only be superficially
copied. For example, Milstein's style is based on the
focus of the shoulder, whereas Perlman utilizes his
big arms and hands in a chopstick style. Gidon Kremer
creates a unique sound by using the whole bow in fast
speeds. The way these great players include these techniques
into their style does not mean that we can isolate these
features and parody them to produce equal results: many
other subtle factors are needed to make a sucessful
performance and it may be to the detriment of the student
to parody these features for the sake of emulating them.
Although the variety is infinite, it is better for beginners
to follow the text book basics in using the bow. At
any level the infinite choice of the bow and the
problems that follows with it will always exist. I always
advise my students to find a bow technique that suits
them the most. When great violinist play the exact same
piece, they use different fingerings and bowings because
they use what is the most comfortable and effective
for their playing. Yet when advising a young player
who cannot make an independent decision, one needs to
be careful. Therfore it is important that the player
is able to experience theoretically correct bowing/fingering
and one that suits their physical features and is able
to make a good decision in making the necessary adjustments
themselves. If the student is critisised too heavily
or put down too much, the student will not be able to
find what is right for themselves and will increasingly
lean on the teacher. Even if what they are doing does
not work very well, the student should be encouraged
to do better rather than critisised. In the past I have
personally experienced that when I was constantly practicing
a certain aspect of playing, the improvement seemed
slow and unnoticeable. Yet when I practised with time
and ease, I showed vast improvement and understanding.
It is more so of young players who are constantly growing
and changing. Same goes for adult students. If one diligently
practices, one can show enormous improvements. At this
point of a student's progress, the use of a mirror is
important because one can monitor the angle of bow on
the string as well as one's general posture. After
having first checked the angle of the bow, one
should then feel the pressure within the bow at that
point of the bow. We cannot know the sound that will
be produced before playing and therefore must practise
to rely on our tactile instincts. The problem occurs
when all too often a player starts to play without any
preparation of any kind. Therefore, one should check
the angle of the bow, feel the pressure (or even just
prepare the pressure in the air) and then adjust the
speed accordingly. At first it takes a lot of mental
effort and time but with pratice this whole process
can become second nature as the reflexes will take over.
It is essential that the metronome is used. We
will now look at the problems that occur with bowing
techniques. When spiccato bowing is difficult due to
very stiff wrist, the first thing that needs to be worked
on must be relaxing and releasing the tension in the
wrist. Without the bow the wrist should be exercised
consistently by turning it 360 degrees. Then the wrist
should imitate brush-stroking motions by moving it in
up and down movements. If these simple exercises were
carried out consistently in any spare moments the student
had (regardless of time and place) the stiff wrist will
become more agile like a well-oiled machine. Of course
the extent of the wrist movement depends on the speed
of the spiccato bowing and as the speed increases the
distance of the string and the bow becomes smaller.
The wrist movement becomes more spring-like. Although
the wrist is relaxed, it is important that the fingers
that are holding the bow should be firm and not be too
loose. It is easier to understand if one thinks of the
finger tips as an extension of the bow. The first finger
controls the direction and angle of the bow and therefore
should not press the bow at all. Meanwhile, the last
finger is very important as it controls the lever (the
thumb) of the bow. A triangle is formed by the first,
last and the thumb which predominantly controls the
bow. Here, the issue of smooth
change of bow will be discussed. This is a universal
problem that any beginner comes up against. It is best
to begin by asking the student to distinguish the different
sound quality of a up and down bow and then asking them
to make them sound the same. If the student cannot do
this, he/she should diminuendo at the end of the bow.
The rough quality of sound in the middle of the bow
can be improved by using a metronome: start with a slow
tempo and increase it to a fast one by counting. Also
by placing a small sticker to indicate the middle of
the bow the student can identify the distribution of
the bow better, and therefore adjust the balance of
the speed and pressure of the bow. The change of the
bow or of the string should be so smooth that it is
undetectable. When changing strings, the point of change
on each string should be fixed so that the change is
as smooth as possible. For example, when changing from
G to E-string, the leap is very large. The two strings
inbetween will not be touched if the point of change
is decided upon. Another problem
that performance can bring out is the change of fingerings.
Players with large hands have a constant problem of
pushing away the fingers in high positions in the E-string,
like Perlman, whereas players with the opposite problem
of small hands face difficulties in playing perfect
fifths, chords, stretching for notes and wide intervalic
leaps or shifts. One must adjust according to one's
own physical limitations. But none of the above mentioned
gets in the way of building up technique and experience.
Great performers such as Kyung-Wha Chung has suceeded
with hands a third that of Perlman's whereas Perlman
is giving beautifully detailed performances despite
his large hands. Chung has said that she uses the fourth
finger constantly to give natural, expressive emphasis
in her performance: it is important to use the relatively
weak fourth finger to strengthen it instead of changing
fingerings to accomodate and avoid the fourth finger.
Therefore, in order to produce a performance where the
fingering is not an obstruction to the music, no finger
from the left hand should have preference over the others.
To build a left hand that is equal in its use of the
fingers, the student should practice scales and trills
in three octaves. Each finger should anticipate the
movement and be close to the string , ready to play.
Economy of movement is important. The pressure of the
fingers should be not too weak or too strong: one should
make the adjustment by judging the sound. If
the left hand is too relaxed there is not enough strength
to articulate but on the other hand, if the hand is
too firm, the player will experience pain. One can only
find out through trial and error. Anything
that is natural is beautiful. It is my belief that any
movement that is the most suited to the physiche of
the individual player is the most natural. Music
is a product of human nature, together with the rest
of the arts, and that is the reason that it has been
revered fever since the ancient times.
|